What's Hot

Great book that changed our perspective on the situation in the Middle East. Auckland 208

Fantastic book. One of the best. People in the book feel very human and inspiring. Auckland 256

A very powerful, heart-wrenching novel. Taupo 007

Although enlightening, the book was crushingly, unrelentingly depressing. Heart-wrenching to see families holding on to hope and love in the face of extreme adversity. Queenstown 10

Everyone found this book upsetting and were moved by it. "Should be read by all" Martinborough 001

We nearly all agreed that this was a story that should be told, but we disagreed on how well the author had done it. Some of us thought that her language was poetic and spiritual, others thought it was embarrassing purple prose. Wanganui 011

The book had a big impact on everybody. Although in recent years we have heard more of the Palestinian side, this brought home the huge bias in the information we had back then. The poetic writing, the descriptions, the emotional impact, the trauma, the daily lives, the Persian poets - so wide ranging with great beauty and humanity. Napier 026

"Mornings in Jenin' was well received by our group. It was the first time any of us had really read anything about the conflict from the Palestinian point of view. One of our group had worked on a kibbutz and her input was interesting. A comment was made that the shuffling from first to third person wasn't a helpful technique, and that there were too many characters, but overall very positive feedback. Christchurch 395

An amazing book. So beautifully and poetically written about lives caught up in both sides of the Palestinian/Israeli conflict. Great love, great sorrow - life and death in generations of families. All this without judgement or taking sides. We very much appreciated this book. Wellington 130

'Mornings in Jenin' was a great hit with the group. We found it a moving insight into the reality of the refugee experience. The characters were convincing, and heroic in enduring the circumstances they were forced into. Hamilton 029

We think this is a five star novel. Beautifully written and you feel as though you are living through it all. Tragic yet somehow beautiful. Highly recommended. Nelson 056

Mixed reaction, but the majority absolutely loved the book - others were 'sickened' by the sad story. A very grim tale! Very rich language, enlightening politically and we learned something of history we didn't understand before - gaining a different perspective. Some found it hard to get into, especially the names. Beautifully written - the turns of phrase and poetry. Christchurch 240

Fantastic book. Everyone agreed that it's the best book we have read over the last year. Clarkville 001

We loved the book. It's magnificent in its sweep and humanity. Wellington 050

A wonderful classic history of China. Easy to read and a great work of art from 1930's. Masterton 005

A very lively discussion on this book - without exception we all agreed this was excellent. Wellington 134

Deservedly a classic that holds up well from 1930's. Universal themes, very well written with 'real' characters. We had a great wide-ranging discussion. Lower Hutt 006

Great book which generated lots of discussion. It provided a window to another world, another time, and intriguing diverse human relations. Christchurch 124

We all loved this book. Pearl Buck's writing style captured the suffering and struggle in the countryside of pre-revolutionary China brilliantly. For many in contemporary China, the hardship and poverty hasn't changed. Wellington 066

All members enjoyed the story very much. All but three had read it years ago. Our discussion was wide ranging, but our collective knowledge of China was shared and commented on. We discussed the importance to Wang Lung of the "good earth". Christchurch 078

An interesting insight into life in pre-Revolution China. Although written over 80 years ago, it is a timeless piece and could be set in any patriarchal rural society. The characters were not very sympathetic, but complex and interesting. The conditions of life portrayed were brutal - childbirth, begging etc. Overall it was enjoyed by the group, and was a healthy discussion piece. Wellington 153

Great discussion - we all agreed we'd not do well as female partners in pre-revolution China! Takaka 003

Very easy to read - some of us had read it years before. Very good insights into the value of land for the earlier Chinese, and shocking to see the way women were treated as little better than "farm animals". In spite of O-lan's exceptional care of Wang Lung, she was still regarded as little better than a beast of burden....Dunedin 066

Loved it - every one of us ! Good old classic! Taupo 003

Most of us had read this book in our "younger days", and we discussed how our understanding of the issues had changed. We discussed the issue of land also, and how all cultures have a basic understanding of our dependence on the land, and the need to respect it. Feilding 002

This book followed a classic storyline ie/ a poor man wanting wealth, who becomes rich and unhappy, and gains a new appreciation for his humble beginnings. It was a very well written and compelling read. An excellent book enjoyed by all in our group. Tauranga 034

Half of our group really enjoyed this book, and the other half were lukewarm, but everyone had read it, which is unusual in our group! It was very technical at times, but not beyond the realms of possibility. It was thought-provoking in many ways. Christchurch 239

Several of us thought it was the best book we had read in a long time. Some did not enjoy it at all, finding it too scientific. Palmerston North 029

We all loved this book! It led to a great discussion of human nature and individual human worth. Personally, I had to keep reminding myself that it was not a true story! Auckland 236

'The Martian' scored a 7 out of 10 by those who finished the book. Our group found the story an interesting concept, a light read, and enjoyable particularly as unexpected things happened to the hero. Of interest was the manner in which Watney kept finding ways to stay alive, despite all sorts of impossible odds. Most found the ending poor and a "let-down'. The book highlighted the enormous logistics (and cost!) involved in such a mission, and the potential for massive problems if every contingency isn't planned for. A most enjoyable meeting. Christchurch 320

Loved it! Auckland 143

Those who finished the book enjoyed it. The discussion was animated and wide ranging, with an interesting variety of opinions. Some enjoyed the book more after seeing the movie, others vice versa. Most found the technical information boring. Northland 003

There was too much detail, however most really enjoyed the book and found it humorous. It would be a great book to introduce to College students, to gear them towards science studies. Mangawhai 001

Loved the book...We acknowledge the suffering. Promise to tell our children. Christchurch 279

The book was easy to discuss because there were so many aspects to it... A tragic story – well written. Hamilton 026

It was a most compelling read and invoked a good discussion and interest in the movie. Te Pirita 001

Loved it - cried, despaired, learnt. New Plymouth 012

A great book, sad, ugly and it provoked a great deal of anger towards mans inhumanity. The character of Sarah was well drawn and we felt protective of her. Long discussion. Auckland 271

We all loved this book. A wonderful insight into Mosque family life and its sad transition into modernity and revolution. Christchurch 257

We all thought this book was very good. Great writing, evocative and a great way to get a bit of history. Wanaka 012

Everyone thought it was a very worthwhile read. Great discussion and a wide range of issues covered. Auckland 039

Really liked this book. It was a simple story told like a fable but incorporated real historical characters and events. Te Awamutu 003

A noteworthy book; it left a strong impression of Iranian culture on us all. Not all found it a comfortable read for style and content however. The Arabic storytelling style takes some getting used to. The way it trivialises some trauma, expands on some trivia, glosses over outrage...makes it harder to empathise with characters. Not all our group were comfortable reading of inequal and degrading treatment of females. Definitely a thought provoker veiled in a grim fairytale, with an insight into the revolution that overturned the Shah. Whitby 003

Everyone really enjoyed this book - the skill of the author in giving us a picture of the family of the mosque brought it all to life. Many of the group were surprised at how much they enjoyed it, despite initial misgivings. The family tree at the beginning of the book was very helpful at identifying the various family members and their roles. A very skilful blend of the personal and the political - we felt we gained many insights into that particular time in Iran's history, and the portrayal of the conflict between the Western influences of the Shah, and the rise of Islamic fundamentalism....Matamata 001

Some people found it depressing, while others enjoyed reading about the history and culture. People really enjoyed the "grandmothers" who went off to Mecca and didn't return. Warkworth 006

The chance to read it was appreciated by all members - we learnt a lot. A moving account of how American influence and changes in Iran's political power left people completely disempowered, confused and disillusioned by the way age-old values suddenly no longer counted. Taupo 005

We found this a very good and sympathetic (although sometimes horrific) book about the unsteady transition from the time of the Shah in Iran, to the Sharia law state. Lots of characters, beautifully drawn. Dunedin 058

A couple of people really enjoyed it. The majority persevered and enjoyed it more at the end. Some thought it lacked the depth of description to 'see' and 'smell' the bazaar etc, and that it lacked a writer's 'voice'. Having said that. the discussion was robust and very interesting. Auckland 343

Very enjoyable read. Serious issues and historical fact written in a readable way, Timaru 016

We enjoyed this book and the insight it gave into the lives of both American Indians and the colonists. We admired the authors integration of her research into the story-it was so smooth. We reacted to the misogyny of the Europeans and were fascinated by the Harvard details. Those of us who hadn't read her other books were encouraged to. At least one member questioned the reality of Bethia's character (being so good). Ngongotaha 001

This was a great book, most of us rated it 8/10. Stimulating discussion-generated from very good questions. Rotorua 006

All enjoyed it except two. Thought provoking. Well researched and written. Language appropriate for the time. Could be a good choice for a book read on radio. Christchurch 009

Rather uneven - slow start then tried to compress a lot into the second half. Members were divided in their opinions which led to a lively discussion. Wanganui 008

Everyone enjoyed the book and the discussion covered many topics. her style of writing appealed to all. Motukarara 001

We unanimously voted this a good book...appreciated the insight into life in the 1600s. There is 'a lot to this book' and for such an unusual topic we found it held our interest the whole way through. Napier 021

Mixed reviews. A number of members found it difficult to 'get into' but were pleased they persevered. Auckland 105

All except two members enjoyed the novel. Very interesting and informative history. Characters well drawn and believable. Comprehensive research filled out the story round the real people. Blenheim 003

We ranged from very enthusiastic to those who had been unable to finish it due to disinterest. All acknowledged it was very well written, and described the Puritan society and its interaction with the local environment well, but it was too long and wordy, so some members skipped a lot. Wellington 117

A wonderful book; thoroughly recommended by all of the book group. We had a lively discussion about the role of women at that time, and the relationship between the indigenous people and the English...Taupo 006

We are glad we, as women, didn't live in this period!! The world hasn't changed much for some countries though. Auckland 013

Wonderful weaving of the social mores of the time. Beautiful writing and authentic scene setting, but not universally loved. Nelson 044

One of the best books we have had in the last year. The story of an Indian boy and a Puritan girl's friendship in the mid/late 1600's. It described the differences between their lives and religions, and how their lives changed when they got to Harvard - Caleb to study, and Bethia as an indentured servant. Christchurch 010

Half of the group found the book difficult to get into. The remainder found it interesting, with the language of the era cleverly done. The discussion centred around the oppresion of women at that time, then moved on to similar regimes in other parts of the world in modern times. Christchurch 317

An interesting book that raises a lot of questions about aid to developing nations. Set in Rwanda, parts of the book are, not surprisingly, harrowing, but it focuses on the future, not the past brutality, and is a surprisingly positive and uplifting book. Christchurch 299

An excellent read. One of our members e-mailed Alissa at Heaven, and received an instant reply. They are still there, and their little boy is now 5 years old. Josh is working for a different organisation now. Great discussion. Stratford 001

We all thought this was an important and worthwhile read. It was shocking to read a little of the genocide in Rwanda, and also inspiring to read about the country's process of healing and recovery. Our discussion went in many different directions; so a very thought provoking read. As host, the recipes were great for supper!! We can recommend the "South of the Equator", and the Nutmeg cake! Mapua 001

We enjoyed the book. We found it an easy read, and it gave us a great insight into the country of Rwanda. For many of us, the book has inspired an interest in Rwanda and its history. Some of us found the constant reference to the USA as the gold standard quite irritating, and we have a slight cynicism towards the situation where the author was dealing with ongoing poverty, while his wife was angsting over quality food and service in the restaurant. We thought it was good that, although the book is set against the backdrop of genocide, it still didn't dwell on it, or allow it to overshadow the story. Pukeko 001

A thoroughly hopeful account of how aid can be successfully dispensed. Recommended by our group. Nelson 051

This book was enjoyed by our whole group. We enjoyed the writing style, and we liked that it wasn't wholly about the genocide but also showed the good that is happening within Rwanda. We learnt a lot about the Tutsi and the Hutu, and how much Belgium had to answer for by dividing the nation. We liked the food descriptions, and we would all like to visit Heaven for a meal, then go on to see the gorillas. Christchurch 196

We felt this book had beautiful, evocative prose. It was easy to visualise the scenery and the situations described. There was some debate about what the book was actually 'about'. Auckland 105

Very enjoyable - beautiful language. We enjoyed the repetition of vivid images - which didn't become mundane. We would have liked a little bit more about the history of Canada however. Wellington 008

We either liked it or not! We wondered if the pervasive sense of loss was either empathised with (or rejected) depending on one's own life experiences. Dunedin 061

A 50/50 split between 'likers' and 'dislikers' of this book. During discussion however, most thought the author's use of words was haunting - his descriptions evoking lots of discussion. Whangamata 001

We all enjoyed it. It's a great read - an excellent story with a clear style and lovely use of language. Wellington 050

All who read this book, without exception, enjoyed it enormously. We thought it beautifully and carefully written without sentimentality. A great read. Wellington 041

Worthwhile read and generally enjoyed. Considerable realism but disappointment that it was not a true account. Thought provoking. Lower Hutt 008

Everyone thought it was a good read. However some thought that the sacrifices and hardships the couples endured were more than intolerable and pointless, after China forbade all Christianity in the northern parts of China, in 1926. Havelock North 008

This book was enjoyed by all members. Most enjoyed the historical aspect and details of the differece in culture. The religious aspect of the story was not sufficient to deter our group from the enjoyment of the book overall. A strangely compelling read. Hikurangi 001

An interesting read for a group which includes a vicar and an atheist! A deeply expressive love story between two exceptionally brave people. Fernside 001

Although several of us approached this book with misgivings (not sure about religious theme), we all enjoyed the story, structure and empathy the author showed. One of the best books this year. Invercargill 002

Our group members enjoyed this book very much, particularly its style and the two voices giving us additional information. There was good insight into China's political history, and changing attitudes towards missionary and European intervention. We also liked reading the notes in the final section which gave us a lot of information about the writer and her grandparents' lives, which provided the source of her story. Doubtless Bay 002

We had a heated discussion about the zeal of the missionaries, and how they took incredible risks with their lives (and that of their families) in order to spread the word of Christianity. Christchurch 145

We found this book instantly engrossing. It was beautifully written, with complex issues of prejudice, superstition and a World War gathered into the simplicity of a tale of family and friendship. Within the sorrow and darkness, there was a thread of hope that we felt balanced the novel with a glimpse of human goodness. Auckland 166

A great read was the verdict on this novel. The setting is the Appalachian mountains, where its remoteness and inbreeding had led to a community riven with superstition and violence. We all felt great sympathy for Laurel and the appalling situation she found herself in. She is the epitome of grace under pressure. The cove itself was a character in the novel, and the descriptions of it sustained the atmosphere of dread and doom. Lower Hutt 004

We found the whole story quite depressing and sad. We were waiting for the happy ending....which didn't come. But it was interesting and not too long a read. Auckland 248

"Deliverance" country well delivered. We liked the way the writer disposed so simply of the main characters with such economy. The group liked the way the narrative "unpeeled". Excellent discussion and good questions. Christchurch 064

'The Cove' is a heartwrenching story of life in a small, quite isolated community where superstition is rife. The main characters are living a drab, subsistent existence with little to look forward to. The book was beautifully written, portraying not only the landscape, but also the hard life of its inhabitants. Our discussion was wide ranging and enlightening. We would recommend it. Paraparaumu 001

A very deep, hugely visual read. We were all totally immersed in the story, characters and the setting. We all felt we would like to read another one of his books. Te Pirita 001

Everyone in our group enjoyed this book - a 'wow' read. We felt the first person narration style worked well, and that Mary Sharratt had researched her subject very effectively. Several in the group did think there was a 21st century 'slant' to Hildegard's thoughts on sexual abuse - it didn't seem to fit with the 12th century likely awareness of these areas? All were keen to read other books by this author. Havelock North 012

We all loved this book...what a fascinating woman Hildegard was. This was well written, and able to put us in the mind of a medieval woman. Evocative description, and incredible detail of life at this time.The story gripped us from the first few pages, although dragged a bit at the end. It stimulated a great and wide-ranging discussion. Tauranga 009

We all enjoyed this book and had great discussions on the place of women in society, from the 1100s through to today. Also on power - power and the Catholic church, power and money, power and men. Tokoroa 001

This book precipitated more discussion than any other this year. Everyone was intrigued, but slightly frustrated about what was fact, and what was fiction.... Auckland 199

It is such a great story - wonderfully written. Great discussion about what women can cope with! Thanks a lot...it was just fascinating! Turangi 001

On the whole, this book was very much enjoyed and gave an easy-to-read illustration of the period. Characterisation was effective. Lively discussion and provocation to learn more about the music of Hildegard von Bingen, the historical backdrop and greater historical detail to ascertain whether her life was 'typical' of the times. Nelson 068

All but one of us completely loved this book - we felt inspired and in awe of the women of those times. Hildegard was such a feisty, courageous person despite the years of adversity. Most of the group would heartily recommend it. Not a hard read, and difficult to put down. Waikanae 010

Two members found the book very difficult to read at the beginning due to the emotional content, but persevered and all admitted it was fascinating. We all learnt so much about religion in that era. An incredible and mesmerising book. I've recommended it to a number of friends. Christchurch 088

We found the first half of the book difficult, but really enjoyed the second part. What a wonderful woman Hildegard was! Dunedin 058

During our discussion of 'Illuminations' we listened to the songs which had been composed by Hildegard von Bingen in the middle ages - an enchanting background for our group. We all agreed that our knowledge of the Crusades was slight - but most enjoyed this adventure and the picture painted of this remarkable Benedictine nun. Te Horo 002

Very divided opinions on this book. Some loved it and enjoyed the writing - others quite dismissive about author's approach to writing a novel about a real person. Greytown 001

Of those who read the book, several were very upset by it, and the remainder thought it was marvellous. An incredible life. Nelson 023

Our highest scoring book this year! Topped both 'The Healing' and 'The Spark'. We had a lot of discussion around the relationship between Hildegard and Richardis, Jutta and her brother Meginhard; the horror of being compelled to become an anchorite (how COULD her mother?), and our admiration for Hildegard's strength. Some of us have listened to her music for years, so it was lovely to read about her. Auckland 037

Some of us found this book disturbing, others found it riveting and inspirational. Well worth reading, however. Christchurch 009

Very enjoyable. Even non sports people enjoyed this. Ohope 5

Everyone thought the book was wonderful, incredibly well written. Christchurch 145

Those who were not interested in tennis found it rivetting and enjoyable. Auckland 37

Everyone enjoyed the book, some interesting discussion about the psychological aspects of being a top sports person. Christchurch 292

All of us loved the book and couldn't put it down. Wellington 134

Good story - but not plausible in some areas. Ohope 004

Reminded us of great novels like 'Jane Eyre', 'Wuthering Heights' - full of suspense, mystery, fraught relationships. Kept us guessing and ending was not expected. Whangamata 001

Most of the members liked the book. Some found it a bit dark for their taste. We had a really interesting discussion as the book is fairly complex with lots of twists and turns to the story. Nelson 041

At first sight it appeared to be a Western and we were not sure about it but it was a fascinating book and led to lots of discussion. Our Methodist minister thought St Agnes was brilliant. Ashburton 009

Surprisingly everyone liked this book...The descriptions of the land and characters were excellent. Some discussion on superstition and mysticism. Auckland 164

Despite the unappealing genre (ie. Western) most agreed this was the best read of the year. Auckland 191

Thomas Eidson generated heaps of discussion and continuing email discussion. Must be good! Wellington 079

Well written and very easy to read and become absorbed in the story. Discussion was lively. Christchurch 136

Well liked by all except one who could not get past the graphic brutality. Generated a lot of discussion. Tauranga 026

The characters were fully drawn and we loved the 'Western' element. Mangawhai 002

We all loved it...great moments of anticipation. Several parts had the heart pounding with anxiety for the characters. Riverton 001

We found it quirky and different - and unpredictable.Harold's journey to Berwick-upon-Tweed was something of a metaphor for one's journey through life. Wellington 036

Charming yet profound at the same time." Christchurch 202

The book was a heart-rending as well as a heart-warming read. It was a beautifully crafted story. Matamata 001

Everyone really loved this book. It was well written and the story gripping. Christchurch 185

An easy-to-read story with likeable characters. Nelson 027

Heart-warming story of human relationships...all about the journey and not the destination. Papamoa 001

We loved this book and all wanted to re-read later to get more out of it. Wanaka 008.

Provoked a lot of discussion, especially remembering our first weeks in London far from home. Ending felt a bit too perfect. A light enjoyable read. Tauranga 019

All enjoyed the book, particularly the evocative and descriptive writing. One member felt it was a 'small' story which led to a lively discussion as to [the] importance of family, life and death. May be on a small domestic scale, but is still huge - and events in the novel set against big events - Depression and World War2. Whitianga 001

We enjoyed the book and it created lots of discussion. It was great that it was written from a male perspective. The epilogue worked as an ending to tie everything together. It was very readable - took a bit to get into, but well worth persevering. Ashburton 013

This book was well received by all the members - that does not often happen. Great characterisation - excellent descriptions and we learned much too. .... Otautau 001

Unanimous approval of this book - one of our best reads. Gave a very good picture of life in a small community. Very well written. Christchurch 108

This was a great source of pleasure for almost all our members, who were impressed by the characterisation of the boys and young men and the way in which the author wove the themes that she had created. The only critical comments that arose in discussion were the negative portraits of the mothers, and the lack of development of the racist implications in Peter's inclusion as a significant part of the interactions...Palmerston North 002

Most enjoyed the book, and liked the Canadian setting - learning something about that country and their contribution in the War. A great depiction of characters - and some good twists and turns! Mana 001

Our group loved this book. The small details of a young man growing up were strung together in a way to expand on what could otherwise have been a very ordinary story. Christchurch 357

All enjoyed the book; fine descriptions of relationships between men and boys, siblings and parents. When set in a small remote town, this emphasises the acute differences and the way each person reacts to the other. Recommended! Masterton 005

This book was well received. Some people found it a little difficult to get into, but generally everyone enjoyed it, particularly her descriptions of the characters and the way she dealt with Canada's side of WW2. Our group found the lake scenes very real and could easily imagine being there. On average it received an 8/10, and everyone is looking forward to reading more of her work. Whitianga 002

Everyone loved the book - unanimous!! Some have read her other 2 books and recommended them. In fact, one member brought Crow Lake along to be passed around the group. We loved the notes! Timaru 007

Very positive reactions. We appreciated the way the intertwining stories emerged. A fascinating portrayal of a remote small community. Very well written with a depth of background knowledge that added great richness. Methven 001

A really lovely little book, beautifully wrought and cleverly constructed. It was a pleasure to immerse ourselves in the lives of the dwellers of this remote valley in Austria; an experience to be savoured. Discussion flowed effortlessly. Coromandel 002

Our group enjoyed this well written book on the whole. We did find it difficult to follow the family trees at times. We would recommend it to other book groups. Waiau 002

Everyone enjoyed the book and felt that each chapter could have been a novel in its own right. It was the only one we've struck that reading the notes first would have helped.Dannevirke 002

A 'unique' book was the comment of one member. We felt it was very well written, and that the readers found themselves right in the landscape, and part of a tight, small community and their perspective of the world which was restricted both in landscape and opportunity. .... Several of us read it twice and felt it improved and was enjoyed more on a second reading. Pahiatua 001

We all enjoyed this gentle book of short stories with a common thread about a time that is gone forever. We were pleased to have the genealogy tables at the beginning! Wellington 074

This book generated much discussion within the group. Most were inspired by the transformation of Conor and his commitment to making a difference in the lives of another "stolen generation"! There was a variety of opinions on the style of writing but unity that this book was a great read for book groups. Richmond 005

Interesting and thought provoking. Raised some issues and controversy relating to methods of assisting poverty especially in the Third World. Dunedin 029

The group unreservedly and unanimously enjoyed this book. It seemed to have everything. Gore 001

A wide ranging discussion on how an individual can make a change. Leithfield 001

An easy read - but really lots of layers. Not a happy story. Good discussion on changed attitudes towards Aids with education and relaxing attitudes and prejudices. Te Pirita 001

Generally enjoyed for its insightful characterisation. Some deliciously amusing dialogue. Thought provoking. Recommended reading. Auckalnd 134

Easy read. Active discussion, particularly around mother/daughter relationship and the style of writing. Napier 024

This book provoked one of the best and longest discussions we have had. While it is not an enjoyable read, it is a thought provoking one. Leigh 001

This book received the highest score of any book that our group has read. Easy read - deceptive depth. Greytown 003

We loved this book - the 'less is more' language and the themes of family and friendship. Great discussion. Auckland 226

It's a must-read classic. Everyone was very moved by this great novel. Harrowing - what's changed? Hikurangi001

Everyone found this a very powerful novel that described the reality of war from a soldier's viewpoint - in graphic detail. It provided much discussion. Well worth reading. Waiau 002

Good discussion about war and families. Dunedin 079

Everyone read the book, many having read it long ago. Well worth the re-read. A marvellous book - terrible and grim subject. It should be mandatory reading for year 12-13 students. Nelson 003

The group found it harrowing. Some didn't finish it. Nevertheless we all found it very worthwhile in its descriptions of what the war was like for the soldiers. We all thought it was very well written. Waikanae 004

Really gripping. It made a deep impression on us. Discussion was lively, about war and innocent young men. Auckland 015

A couple of our group didn't like the author's style, but the rest of the group enjoyed the book immensly. It generated lots of interesting discussion. Nelson 042

Very lively discussion about ethics, families, mothers, illnesses. Thought provoking book. Rai Valley 001

Excellent discussion on moral ethics and stem cell research.... good insights into the stress of a dying child from all members of the family. Worthwhile reading - makes you think about a little known topic. Nelson 023

Everyone thought this book was a good read - thought provoking, with a twist at the end! Waipu 001

Beautifully written. A sad story but not depressing. What a resilient Heroine. Enjoyed by most of the group, including male members. Matamata 003

We all enjoyed the book. Unusual, easy style of writing and good discussion questions and author commentary. Whangarei 008

Most people found this story to be very informative and harrowing in parts but always hopeful. Well written and held our interest. A wonderful woman! Akaroa 001

Everyone loved the book. Best book we have read in book club. Ashburton 020

Beautifully written. Good read. Interesting historical era. Auckland 122

Good first read for book club. A little depressing but great for discussion. Paraparumu 002

We agreed the writing was beautiful and could see that it had been written by a poet. Several of us had read it before and were very happy to reread it. Nelson 007

A superbly written novel - very evocative of early NZ and its narrow-mindedness. Nelson 003

The characters felt authentic, the author's research was thorough - what an amazing and accomplished 'first novel'. Dunedin 061

We all enjoyed this book;its history, cultural setting, location and poetic, gentle writing. Wellington 018

One of our favourites to date. Author did a good job of combining NZ history and views into an interesting and engaging novel. Gore 007

Such a glorious book - sparse, lyrical and poignant. Our group was unanimous in our enjoyment of this book, and we probably had our best ever discussion. Auckland 094

An interesting and easy read of a well-written book, which was enjoyed by everyone in the group. The NZ author has used language romantically, producing wonderfully evocative characters and scenes. The cultural contrasts between the Chinese and New Zealanders led to to excellent discussions, about both the late nineteenth century and the present. Christchurch 010

Our discussion was lively. The group thought the couple's relationship would never have been able to develop fully due to the prejudices of society, and therefore wasn't as interesting to read about as it might have been. We all thought we learnt a lot about how Chinese people were treated in early 20th century NZ, and about some of our country's more shameful past immigration policies. Auckland 322

A relatively simple story with not too many characters,short chapters and very well written. The sensitive handling of the love between a Chinese man and a NZ Wellington widow in the early 20th century was gently portrayed. Our group found the book a delight to read. Wellington 117

This novel promoted a most lively discussion about immigration and related topics. We loved the poetic economy of language and the rhythmic flow of sentences. Hamilton 024

What a fascinating look at early 1900's Wellington, and the relationship between the locals and the Chinese community. The racism was normal for the time, as was the lack of womens' rights. We had a great discussion and all enjoyed the book. Masterton 013

We were impressed by this book - beautifully written and dealing with the issues of the day with sensitivity and skill. The author successfully combined historic facts with the story of the fated relationship. It had contemorary relevance also. Dunedin 029

Everyone enjoyed this book although they all said it was slow reading. We had an interesting discussion about it. Christchurch 356

Lively discussion. All agreed they learnt more about tractors than they thought they would. Interesting family dynamics. Cromwell 005

We loved this book. Most found it funny and the main characters although appearing rather over- the-top were at the same time believable. Palmerston North 006.

Great book with a cast of amazing characters. Funny, sad, annoying yet we took them all to our hearts, even the Dad. Auckland 271

Hilarious, really enjoyed the lighthearted style and exaggerated characters. Northland 002

So many topics covered - historical events, care of the elderly, growing old, immigrants, family relationships and, of course, tractors. Tauranga 034

We particularly enjoyed the clever juxtaposition of 'tractor history' and the colourful plot with larger than life characters. Picton 002

This book got the 'thumbs up' from all our group. Well researched. Tauranga 015

Our favourite book of the year so far. Mostly it took us awhile to read as we got confused by all the places and characters, but it was well worth hanging on as it all came together in the last third or so of the book. Auckland 107

A structured story, meticulously crafted. Carterton 001

Extremely well written. Loved all the characters, how they interlaced. Fantastic story - shame about the circumstances - but inspiring how they survived and the Italian peasants took them in. Winton 002

Quite confusing at times but an amazing story of courage, misery, fear, comradeship and the neverending toil of the Italian people to overcome the worst of the war... Christchurch 011

We all enjoyed the different 'take' on the Holocaust. None of us knew anything about the Italian scenario of WW2, apart from the fact that Kiwis were there. Auckland 133

Gems of wisdom on practically every page and very funny unexpected bits. Whangarei 017

A whodunnit with fragrance and warmth! Wellington 18

Generally agreed a great read. Jenny Pattrick has obviously done her research well and draws us in with her local knowledge of Samoan culture and language. Auckland 55

Another sterling read from the pen of this very engaging author. Masterton 10

Lively discussion covered many themes, cultural, secrets, family, generations, connections, life and its twists and turns. Wellington 130

The majority of the discussion group enjoyed 'Inheritance'; most scoring the book between 7-9/10. Members who had previously read 'The Landing' were able to identify more with the characters and their subsequent development in 'Inheritance'. Katikati 005

The book was enjoyed by some - the story-line and also the range of subjects it touched on. Those who didn't like it were not happy with the characterisation, and felt it was not well constructed. However, it generated a longer than usual discussion, so overall a good book for groups. Tauranga 016

Our group found the book enjoyable. Jenny Pattrick is good at teasing out historical facts and weaving them back into the narrative in a colourful and interesting way. The story had plenty of tension to hold the reader's interest. We felt we could almost feel the heat and humidity of Samoa, and almost smell the frangipani. Auckland 332

This book elicited great passion and dislike in our members. Her depiction of characters and her dialogue came in for the most criticism, with comments like 'cliched', 'unbelievable', and the dreaded 'Mills ands Boon!' We all agreed however that she can spin a rollicking tale, and excels in thorough historical research. We learned a lot about Samoa's past.... Raumati 001

All members of the group enjoyed the book very much. The strengths and weaknesses of the various characters made for interesting reading, and kept us all engrossed in the mystery unfolding. The background of the relationship between Samoa and NZ was an eye-opener for most of us - the bitterness felt by the islanders over the preceived treatment by the NZ government etc. We discussed the character of Jeanie and how powerless she appeared to be, but then she found the strength to break away from her husband's brutality. We also discussed how sometimes it is better to leave the truth hidden. Great discussion ensued from this book. Otorohanga 003

We all agreed that the book was good "story-telling" rather than a literary read, but we got caught up in the characters and wanted to know what happened next, so we were engaged. We thought the title was excellent, and explored some of the thoughts around 'inheritance' eg DNA, nature vs nurture etc. Auckland 335

Enjoyed the humour and good use of language. Otautau 001

Humorous, but with a serious message about racism and non-acceptance of newcomers. Those who grew up in rural England felt it was true of the England we knew. Mangonui 001

Laugh out loud funny in some places. Lower Hutt 004

Quite twee but enjoyable nonetheless. Nelson 17

A sweet take with undertones of racism and snobbery. Characters well developed. Auckland 050

The way social problems and clashes of cultures are presented here, shows the author is a wise woman. Some traditional values make our lives richer, others need to be changed when they no longer are true to our human development. Hamilton 034

We all enjoyed reading of Major Pettigrew. A gentle story of ageing, misunderstandings, long established traditions, family dictates, petty prejudices and communal life in a small village. The character of the Major was well drawn, and we loved his ascerbic dry wit. And we all love a happy ending. Whitianga 002

As anticipated, the group enjoyed this as a great holiday read. While the characters were caricatures and stock figures to an extent, the inherent humanity and gentle humour fleshed them out. The only jarring note we felt was the "heroic" rescue on the cliff at the end. Te Horo 002

Some of us thought that this book was wonderful; funny, clever dialogue, original similes and metaphors and a satisfying ending. Others considered it contrived, 'obviously' a first novel, boring and difficult to finish. The diversity of opinion was unusual and very marked. Possibly it is a novel that would appeal more to women than to our group, which is all men. wanganui 011

Thoroughly enjoyable - a laugh out loud experience! Well written with great characters. Christchurch 238

Beautiful book that everyone loved - highly recommended. If we had to mark every page that a gem was found, every page would be marked. Otorohanga 003

Three(female) members of the group thoroughly enjoyed the pace and themes of the book, while others felt that Helen Simonson had been away from England too long, and the kind of East Sussex village she depicts doesn't exist anymore... The characters and the situations did not feel real or particularly engrossing, but a couple of members pointed out how nicely the moments of falling in love were described, with weather effects to match... Auckland 376

Wonderful. A superbly written social satire, told with humour and evidencing a deep understanding of human foibles. Entrenched racism, a study of English manners and gentility, a love story and a questioning of modernity and mores of the younger generation all combine to provide an entertaining yet provocative read. Highly recommended. Otaki 001

A good read and well discussed. This was the first 'whodunnit' we've had and it succeeded by keeping us reading and capitavated right to the end. Palmerston North 006

A beautifully written book with enough twist to keep us guessing until the end. Excellent characterisation and character development. Pahia 003

General concensus was an excellent book with a very thought provoking story, varied and interesting characters. Very happy to recommend as an excellent crime, mystery novel. Hamilton 034

Everyone enjoyed. Lots of debating over the ending. Timaru 011

A beautiful tale of sisterly love. We felt drawn into the tragic story and Beatrice's frantic search for her missing sister. Wanaka 011

40 years on, a second reading for most of us and we were enthralled by this book! Our most lively discussion yet and we covered it all - life in small town, racism, parenting, the legal system, gun laws... A superb book with great characters, especially Atticus and the children. Cromwell 003

We all thoroughly enjoyed and appreciated revisiting this extraordinary novel. The author's style of writing was engaging and the very serious social issues she tackled are sadly as relevant today as when the book was published. Palmerston Nth 006

This book deserves its classic status - multilayered, insightful, gripping plot. Great characterisation. Highly recommended. Palmerston Nth 025

The book received the highest score of any book that we have read! Greytown 003

Excellent book. 'Superb wordsmithing'. Whangarei 016

This book was well received by all. A very interesting but frightening part of New Zealand's history. Wellington 057

Everyone 'enjoyed' this book more than they expected. It wasn't sensationalised, and they thought it was written very matter-of-factly. Auckland 224

All enjoyed this book: 'incredible read', 'brilliant book', 'should be compulsory' etc. Dunedin 044

All loved the book. Many sought further books of the Baxter family. Taupo 003

All at our meeting really enjoyed this book. We each brought a collection of flowers from our garden and found their meanings from this book. Morrinsville 001

There were polarized views in our group. Some liked the premise of a "language of flowers" and others felt it was "romantic twaddle".We all agreed that it is lightweight, and some characters are fey and unrealistic. However, we had a decent discussion around fostering, families, love and acceptance. Dunedin 090

All members enjoyed this book and were captivated by the meanings of flowers. There was much interesting discussion on 'damaged' people like Victoria in the book. Two members experienced in counselling and early childhood doubted the book's happy ending, noting that such people tend to require on-going professional help as well as ordinary support. Gore 001

This provided a good insight into the thoughts of a foster child; the effects of rejection and the fragility of the soul. Shocking in parts but beautifully written. Recommended. Te Puke 006

If we had read this one earlier, it could well have been our favourite book. We all loved it - an original story served up with a bouquet of flowers. It was all the more poignant when we learned that the author had fostered and adopted herself.We all brought flowers and learnt and discussed their meaning - a great book. Whitby 002

There was a wide variety of comments. Some felt the author tried too hard to make up a story around the theme of 'language of flowers'; and that all the characters were dysfunctional. Others found it an easy read, light but sometimes disturbing. Whakatane 005

In general, people liked the book. It was interesting to read, well structured and full of symbolism. It was beautifully written, and dealt with a unique subject well. The central character had had a tough life, with some hard experiences, but her love of flowers brought out a softness and a sense of hope. The discussion went well; the questions were thought-provoking and relevant Christchurch 403

Overall the group loved the book, and would highly recommend it. It was fascinating to analyse the meaning of different flowers, and how messages could be conveyed... Mangaweka 001

We mostly enjoyed this, and found the characters believable if not especially likeable. The ending was a bit unsatisfactory - ' Downton Abbey-ish' in its tying up of loose ends in a happy ever after way. Insightful re the effects of serial fostering and a poor start to life on the behaviour of a child and young adult. We had mixed feelings about the structure of the book - some liked, but some were annoyed by, the to and fro of it. Auckland 107

We all loved this book. It is a lovely story - very sad in places, but the added element of the flowers and their meanings elevates it to a beautiful novel. We were delighted that the fractured little family came together at the end. Highly recommended. Otorohanga 003

Most members enjoyed this book. There were some reservations about the alternating past and present chapters format. Ashburton 024

Beautifully written. We enjoyed the alternating chapters, which were woven together nicely. It stimulated an interesting discussion about fostering practices in NZ. Paihia 003

Very thought provoking. A realisation of the cruelty in the world ... Everybody felt the characters were well defined as was their struggle to survive. Napier 020

It was good to be reminded of the reality of living in a war zone. The characters were very real, yet the ideas they conveyed transcended the individual and became huge concepts we all have to grapple with. An excellent read. Masterton 003

A long and insightful discussion. Highly recommended. Christchurch 324

Everyone in the group thought this an excellent book, with its scarce language vividly portraying the various individuals' suffering. The reality of the conflict and the hopelessness of the situation for the residents of Sarajevo is apparent. Dunedin 007

This was a highly rated story amongst our readers. Google helped in finding the piece of music that the cellist played...Tauranga 015

Interesting and a challenge. Great insight into the daily life in a war torn city...Lots of discussion generated on how we would deal with a similiar situation. Auckland 280

Everyone got a lot from this book. Lively discussion, and research by some to learn more about this time in Sarajevo. The writing was so good-very spare, poetic almost, and conveyed so much in a few words...Nelson 007

An absolutely wonderful book. This would be our best `pick` of the year. It was written in a way that we could feel the experience of the characters. Wellington 029

Although everyone liked the book, most felt uncomfortable using the word `enjoyed`. Reading about war can be uncomfortable but this was easier as it did not glorify it and told the human story. It was interesting to see how each character kept their humanity. Dunedin 039

We all loved the book - it forced us all to do some research on the conflict. There were interesting observations made on the three main players, and their survival under the terrible conditions of everyday life. Auckland 265

We found it a beautiful and profound read, providing a picture of the futility of war and its impact on individuals, families and communities. The character of Arrow was more fully drawn, and we found it interesting the way she depersonalised the killing, by means of changing her name and various other strategies. Christchurch 319

Overall the book was well regarded by the group. Some people found the middle part a bit disjointed and would have preferred that the three main characters be linked to make a more cohesive story. Evocative and moving as regards the devastation and ruination of the war. Wellington 202

We thought Helen shared the story with honesty and joy and humility. there is an ongoing all-pervasive spiritually in the book of the relationships, and depths of those relationships. Christchurch 243

We enjoyed the writing style and had several discussions about issues raised - the influence of animals on families, the ill and dying, dealing with tragedies etc. Ashburton 003

We loved the local (Wellington and Auckland) flavour, the raw self-deprecating voice, and it kicked off a lively sharing of our own pet and grief/recovery stories. Lower Hutt 006

All enjoyed the book and a good talk about our own animals followed. Invercargill 015

Everyone had a different opinion about cats vs dogs and grief vs moving on. Very stimulating conversation. Easy read. Cromwell 002

A well-liked book-amusing too. Tragic beginning. A big discussion - it made us pause (paws!) for thought. Cambridge 005

Thoroughly enjoyed this book. All agreed `death` was so openly shared and discussed. Animals do play a huge role in helping with grief. 10/10. Te Pirita 001

Terrific discussion. Most of us are over 80 and resolved to start brain exercising before it's too late. A really interesting book. Hamilton 007

Such an enlightening and enthralling read. Everybody had a connection to this book. We applied the theories to education, music, health and everyday living. Leigh 001

Provoked plenty of discussion regarding the many areas of brain damage covered in the book, plus the veracity of the research. Wellington 005

Not a book to go to bed and read. You needed to concentrate. Fascinating. Thoroughly enjoyed by the group. Auckland 050

A great read. We all learned a lot & so we had a good discussion. Most of us intend to buy the book as a reference book. Wellington 130

The group loved the book and thought it was up-to-date, educational, well written.The discussion was lively and personal connections to the content of the book were made. Everyone should read it. Christchurch 095

A rollicking good story of its time, with well described characters and an interesting plotline. Christchurch 071

A delightful way to learn NZ history. Tauranga 022

Lots of discussion re cultural relations between Pakeha and Chinese and Maori and current state of play today. Palmerston North 029

'Landings' was a very popular book with us...All like Jenny Pattrick's style of writing and will be looking for more of her books in the library. Tauranga 005

A popular choice. Impressive research and evocation of the period and natural environment. Some issues with the actual plotline and possibly some caricatures of characters. Dunedin 029

Probably the book that members have enjoyed most so far. We all loved the way the history was interwoven with the story. We are already planning a group trip to the Whanganui River. Jenny Pattrick is a popular, 'easy to read' and compelling author. Te Horo 002

This book was of most interest to our readers interested in NZ history, or who were familiar with the area. Not the best of Jenny Pattrick's novels. Christchurch 357

We absolutely loved this book, as many of us have travelled in this area. We could picture the places the story is set in. It was lovely to read the connection between "Landings" and "Inheritance" - Bridie's baby is the half Chinese 'John O'Dowd' in "Inheritance". We loved the history of the Whanganui River. Otorohanga 003

This book started the most animated discussion of the year. Everyone was pleased they had read it. A little dark like all of Jenny Pattrick's books. Well researched, and a "don't want to put it down" book. Christchurch 294

A good book. Everyone enjoyed it and gave it 9/10. The descriptions of the area around the Whanganui River, made us wish we could have been there when the river was such an important and thriving highway. Masterton 013

Opinions were divided on this book - some were 'underwhelmed' by it. Others enjoyed the read, and it sparked an interest in visiting the Whanganui River and surrounding areas. Auckland 344

We all enjoyed this book. Some were able to share personal stories from the region. So nice to read a book set in NZ for a change. Recommended! Auckland 302

Loved the book, beautiful style of writing. Would definitely read the author's other novels. Kaikoura 001

Enjoyable mixture of suspense and history. A different look at society after WW1. Rotorua 004

Thought provoking look at the way women's rights and expectations have evolved in the last century. We enjoyed it. Alexandra 003

All members of the group enjoyed this book and we had a long discussion about the era it was written in and style-all felt that there were several plots within the story. Paihia 003

We all thoroughly enjoyed this book. One member commented, " I loved her determination to have what she wanted and to love in so many ways". Interesting to read the history notes also. Napier 024

Our group enjoyed the book and it led to discussions on women in the work force in those early pioneering years. Masterton 011

Wonderful! For once all our members agreed on this. Well written, informative and kept us guessing. An addictive read. Auckland 060

Enjoyed the book. It covered an area of life that rang bells for members. Auckland 013

We loved this book. The dawning of the women's lib must have been very difficult for some women. We do not appreciate enough what we owe them. Geraldine 002

A bit slow. Didn't keep everyone's attention, but those who finished it enjoyed it. Auckland 347

An enjoyable read about a time in history which we knew little about - womens' first experiences of/in the legal profession in the 1920s. Several topics covered, although not in great detail, were: childrens' rights, mass deportation of children to the colonies, and the fact that women were considered second class citizens. Auckland 284

Discussion was lively. Some disappointment in the 'Mills & Boon' love interest, but overall everyone enjoyed the various sub plots and twists. It took a while to get into but picked up pace. Havelock North 011

A very good meeting and discussion. There was a lot of animated discussion on the subjects raised in the book. Probably the most successful book we have read this year. Wellington 142

Fantastic! We unanimously agreed that we LOVED this book! We liked the themes of love, and the women of the 1920s taking over the role of men following the war. The plot was thrilling and the second half of the book a complete page turner. We couldn't put it down - wonderful! Queenstown 010

Opinion was divided, with some readers very enthusiastic about it. The majority appreciated the author's writing, but had reservations about the novel as a whole. It was thought that there were too many themes within the story - family secrets and tensions, the plight of orphaned children, the trauma of war, a murder trial, and the mores of the times which discouraged the ambitions of women to pursue a career of their choice and to further their education. However the choice of book led to an interesting discussion about our own families, the lives lived by our parents and grandparents, and our own childhood and adolescence experiences in the 40s and 50s.

Wellington 007

This book sparked vigorous discussion - most loved it for its slow pace, extraordinary biological detail...but most of all for the subtle parallels drawn between the snail's life and the author's illness. Wellington 012

Big discussion about snails, getting over sickness and caring for something (the snail). After this read everybody will treat little animals differently. Turangi 001

We thought the format was beautiful and really enjoyed the quotations. Found [the author's] research and observation of snails fascinating. Coromandel 002

We found it difficult to put down. It gave us an insight into Hawaiian history and the island of Moloka'i. We liked the 'realness' of each character in the story. Carterton 001

The discussion on [the book] and its subject was the best we've had for months! Lots of personal stories about similar subjects (TB, polio). New Plymouth 013

All enjoyed this beautifully written story. Found historical information very interesting. Christchurch 125

A unanimous "best sell" for our bookgroup.Alan Brennert had clearly studied his subject matter thoroughly and presented his novel in a manner that brought his characters to life. Palmerston North 2

Mixed feelings from the group. We thought he should maybe just have written the book as non-fiction. A number didn't finish it. Christchurch 360

A few of us were amazed that the book had been written by a man, as a woman's emotions were so well portrayed. Also by the fact that the author was a screen writer - when will we see a film? There was robust discussion about leprosy, and how long it took to find a cure. Auckland 016

Most members were pleased to have read this book, and to have learnt more about an era and disease they had little prior knowledge of. However, it was widely agreed that the writing style and continuous highs and lows of the linear plot were frustrating. Auckland 381

A great read. Heartbreaking situation in beautiful surroundings. Well drawn characters and interesting relationships. It made us all dip into current research on this terrible disease. We enjoyed the 'Get to Know the Author' and the 'Get to Know the History' sections at the back of the book. All agreed we would recommend this book to others. Hokitika 001

Generally, the book was found to be well-written, informative and well-paced. It was sobering rather than enjoyable however, and some saw it as overly graphic, overlong and sometimes contrived. We were all pleased that it had a happy ending! The discussion was rich, two of the group having visited a leper colony, and the questions prompted some good exchanges on, for example, whanau, fa'afafine and fear of the unknown. Tairua 001

We loved this book - average of 8/10. We were transported to Hawaii, and were moved by the main character Rachel. It was very educational about leprosy in those times. Taupo 007

The book was a popular choice! It was really interesting and gave us a good insight into the real lives that lepers lived in recent history. Well researched and an easy to read story. Queenstown 010

Everyone very much enjoyed the book, partly for the very interesting information about how leprosy was treated at the end of the 19th century, but also for the picture of the islands created by the author, and the warmth and colour of the characters. They came alive for us and added to the interest of the story....We all admired Rachel's strength of character and her resourcefulness, and were glad to follow the course of her life right through to the end. Katikati 001

The writers skills and links to historical fact, the writing of the symphony and the intense characterization were all applauded. Timaru 007

Very positive comments from the group, in particular the way the main characters were depicted...It brought up comparisons with 'The Cellist of Sarajevo'. Napier 016

This book was the highlight of our year. Discussion was dynamic and forthcoming. Lower Hutt 011

"Original, quirky,memorable, 'feel good'." Havelock North 008

"Compelling reading, interesting political time. Good group discussion and enjoyed on several levels." Christchurch 222

"Just what we needed post quake! Easy read." Diamond Harbour 001

"It was a wonderful portrayal of humanity overcoming the scourge of racism. The characters were so real, the humour was delightful..." Nelson 019

The group, except for one, found it to be an astonishingly good book. Extremely well written and set in a diverse and complex scenario. Thoroughly recommended. Christchurch 166

Our group enjoyed this moving story and the skilful writing style, combining historical events and storytelling. Auckland 167

We enjoyed this intelligent and well written book and it generated much discussion within the group. We would recommend this book. Paraparaumu 001

There was a mixed reaction to this book. The majority enjoyed it appreciating its overall plot and themes of national identity and a possibly unfulfilled life. Auckland 015

Could have been our best book and therefore best discussion this year. Members loved the combination of novel, character and politics. Hamilton 007

An amazing story, one that we all thoroughly enjoyed. Written in a fairly light-hearted manner, it nevertheless covered all the emotions. A great lesson in geography and history; well written with good characters. Quite thought-provoking with many "what ifs" - very much recommended. Whitby 002

The members all agreed that the book was a worthwhile read. We enjoyed seeing the development of Feliks, from a non emotional, static introvert, to his realisation that a perspective of events had a bearing on perception. Circumstances led him to meet his brother, which set him on a path to investigate changes in Europe, politics and eventually to confront his past. Finding overwhelming emotion when hearing from his mother, helped Feliks to realise he was not just an onlooker, but actually part of a relationship. He no longer thought only of himself, but came to realise he belonged to a home, family and friends. Katikati 001

We liked the book. It was interesting that a lot of things that happened to the main character, were perceived by his brother to mean the opposite. The politics/war was interesting but overbearing at times. It led to a varied discussion on perspectives, war time and history. Auckland 248

Most of the group found it a challenge, but it created a long discussion. Christchurch 262

We thought that parts of this book (ie the mother's letter) were very well written, but most of us found the constant self examination and politics of the narrator repetitive and, at times. tedious. Tauranga 038

"Clever writing" was the consensus of opinion. The questions gave us much to discuss and think about. Hamilton 024

A favourite with the group. A book to read on a wet day – it can't be put down. Nelson 051

We found this story of 5-year-old Jack [and his mother] very evocative, compelling and thought provoking...We all loved this top read. Masterton 005

A disturbing book but extremely well written and a gripping read. Wellington 107

Well thought out – telling the story through the child's eyes gave a whole new perspective...and from a mother's perspective how to keep a child healthy, educated and happy in almost impossible circumstances. Tauranga 018

Great read - disturbingly interesting. Christchurch 274

What a marvellous fellow. A little egotistical! ... All husbands read it as well. Christchurch 294

Such drive and ability to absorb new skills. An insight into 'aid' in other countries.Coromandel 001

How encouraging to read how someone overcame personal abandonment and channelled his life into helping others.Tauranga 004

We all agreed this is an inspirational book, at times provocative, but Ray Avery's story together with his colleagues deserves to be one we should all know... We could have gone on and on talking about the book." Taupo 006

We all unreservedly loved this book. A powerful story beautifully told, as it stays with you after you'd finished it. Matua 001

Great deal of discussion. A very insightful (but at times scary) book and timely for our age group. Not sad despite the topic...quite hopeful. Christchurch 065

It was a 10. Everyone thought it was a great book – even though it made us aware of our own mental fallibility! Very well written. Auckland 020

A positive sensitive portrayal of Alzheimers. Christchurch 125

We found this to be an inspiring book...This was an easy read with so many messages in the story, an insight into a different world and culture. Tauranga 018

The book stimulated much discussion about aid to developing countries and the importance of using local skills and knowledge...would love to know what happens in his [William's] life after the book. Matamata 001

This book was universally applauded and we all enjoyed it immensely. Liked the first person writing, the intelligence, tenacity and ability to 'make do'...Hamilton 010

The retrospective telling of the story of Ines through the eye-witness accounts makes the reader work, think, nut-out what is happening here. Mana 001

Excellent book with lots of discussion about the mother-child bond. A thought-provoking rather than an enjoyable read. Auckland 050

All his [the author's] books are "˜just so different' and yet every one has been enjoyable and engaging. No one was disappointed with this very different story. Auckland 133

Clever writing with good descriptions. A truly international story. Christchurch 071

"We loved the great story richly told with wonderful descriptions of Persian life in the 17th century. We had lots of discussion about the position of women, attitudes to sex, harshness of life then, the food and value of rugmaking." Christchurch 143

"Entrancing story. Fantastic historical tale." Christchurch 229