Title: Tally Stick, The
Authors: Nixon, Carl
Genre: Fiction: New Zealand
Pages: 286
Year: 2020
Language: English
Description: Given the lushness of West Coast vegetation, it is no surprise to hear that back in 1978 when the Chamberlain family - John, Julia and their four children - were in an accident, their car was never recovered. So how on earth was it possible that in 2010 the remains of one of the children were found, with evidence that Maurice had lived for four years after the crash. How was this possible and where was the rest of the family? And why was Maurice in possession of a tally stick, indicating that he owed a debt?

Told from multiple viewpoints, this evocative story of adaptation and identity is so believable that it will have you wondering if in fact these events did occur.

Categories: Fiction NZ, Contemporary, Grief/loss, Medical/Health, Morals/Ethics, Mystery, Relationships, 2022 Titles, Larger font, Staff pick


[Please log in to write a review]
By: DOYLE 001 2022-06-22 13:11:31
Most members agreed it was a compelling read. Not the most enjoyable story, but well crafted though, and so believable. Some couldn't put the book down.

By: NEWP 022 2022-05-27 14:18:35
All agreed that the writer did an excellent job of writing the story as all wanted to keep reading despite the unpleasant topic. One reader did point out that falling off a cliff seemed a simple end compared to the other twists and turns of the story. Overall a good read and we always like to read a New Zealand novel.

By: CHCH 508 2022-05-06 12:56:19
Apart from one dissenter, this book was thoroughly enjoyed. Well crafted.

By: TAUP 011 2022-03-30 14:38:25
The group all enjoyed the book, but found the storyline quite upsetting. The description was vivid and transported you to the situation. Most couldn't put the book down, and some went back and re read it, as it left you wondering about how and why some situations occurred. Overall a good read but very sad.

By: ALEXA 001 2022-03-07 11:31:08
The Book Club members had a good discussion of the book. We thought the setting had a malevolence which set the scene for the story that followed. The survival of the fittest was suggested with regard to the West Coast in the 1970s/80s. Despite that, the description of the landscape was poetic at times. The accident was believable, we found similarities to a recent accident in the North island, where a motorist left the road and down a bank in dense bush. In summary, we thought it was a well-written atmospheric novel with Darwinian overtones.

By: STEW 001 2021-12-17 11:58:11
Evocation of atmosphere was skillfully done. Plot development quite compelling - the reader wanted to read on.....

By: TAUR 004 2021-12-13 14:15:39
Everyone thought this book a great read. Gripping and atmospheric. Most read it all at once because they couldn't put it down. Realistic and suspenseful. Descriptive writing put the reader right into the setting.

By: MARTO 004 2021-11-01 11:17:07
Mixed review - some felt a bit 'flaky'. More of a 'short' story. But loved the West Coast aspect.

By: DOUBT 001 2021-09-17 13:39:57
All except one enjoyed this book. We found the book easy to read and difficult to put down. A great storyline which kept you guessing throughout.

The Book Discussion 
Scheme is a member of the Federation of Workers Educational Associations in Aotearoa New Zealand
BDS is a member of the Federation of Workers Educational Associations