Sorrow and Bliss
Mason, MegWhat on earth is the matter with her? From childhood through to adulthood, Martha is renowned for her spikiness. To be honest, even though there is wit and charm, she is just plain difficult. Even her husband Patrick, who has loved her since he was fourteen, can't seem to make her happy.
Narrated by Martha and laced with a vein of dark humour, this is a poignant story with clever writing that sensitively handles the complex realities of mental illness, from the sorrow to the bliss and everything in between.
Pages
341
341
Year
2020
2020
Reviews
25-09-2024
Mixed reaction: half liked it, half didn't; most found it a slow start but appreciated the ending. The few that finished it were a little frustrated by the diagnosis but also found it more happy than sad, despite the mental and environmental circumstances. Perspectives were believable, realistically complicated; even the minor characters were well-written, notably Winsome.
17-09-2024
Some in the group gave this book 5 stars and others a 2. Main characters were described as frustrating which may account for lower rating and opinion. Others felt it captured the complexities of Mental Illness for the person who suffers and the family/friends very well. A lot of robust discussion and varied opinions.
01-05-2024
This book raised a discussion about the treatment of people with mental illness. It was a worthy read, although not always an easy subject.
15-01-2024
This book turned out to be quite beautiful, sad but not depressing, tempered by the author's wonderful ironic humour and understanding of the human spirit. It was amazing how much in-depth discussion and sharing emerged from it.
03-08-2023
Sad but also witty, thought-provoking and well-written.
22-06-2023
A terrific discussion by our group - most knew of someone who had similar "symptoms". Some humour lifted the novel.
08-06-2023
Difference in opinion around the fact that the mental illness was not actually named. Well-written, although most would not recommend it. Really appreciated the different characters and what they brought to the story.
07-06-2023
The group was really conflicted about this book! Some really connected with the portrayal of mental health issues and the message around who is a victim of a person's mental illness. Others found the humour jarring and the main character frustrating.
24-04-2023
The word "enjoy" didn't arise in our discussion, but most members felt that they gained more understanding about the impacts of mental illness - both on the individual, and also their family and friends. Certainly a thought provoking read.
04-04-2023
A mixed reaction to this book, most enjoyed it, some loved it, others were frustrated with the author for failing to resolve one crucial detail. Most enjoyed her writing style and humour, although several found the main character irritating at times - although conceded this might have been a deliberate ploy by the author to highlight the difficulties of coping with people with mental illnesses.
09-01-2023
Some struggled to get into this book.
09-01-2023
One person in our group loved it. The rest thought it was well-written but depressing.
19-12-2022
Slightly mixed reviews. Beautifully written, and a real insight to mental health. Most were impatient with Martha's destructive behaviour.
17-11-2022
The whole bookclub LOVED this book and it generated a big discussion about mental health.
12-10-2022
Five of our group chose not to finish. Two enjoyed it ( though not 'raving' about it). The other three did not enjoy it.
12-10-2022
Some in the group didn't like the book, but it did prompt interesting discussion on depression and mental illness. We all agreed it gave a better insight and perspective from the main character's point of view.
12-10-2022
Group thought the book was over-hyped and disappointing.
27-07-2022
Fabulous!
29-04-2022
Our group members are between 55-77. Some found themselves frustrated with the narcissism and self-absorption of Martha. Some were frustrated with the diagnosis name. All enjoyed the prose and writing style. The minority found it funny, but most found it miserable.