An excellent read. All were engrossed by the themes and the magpie. A lot of discussion. Thank you.

Interesting construct with the story told from the perspective of a magpie. It was an effective technique for some of our group. Others were frustrated by it. Many said they would not recommend it to someone else because of its domestic violence themes.

Most of us enjoyed the book - one "loved it". There was a lot of diverse opinion expressed in discussion - some found it repetitive, some were critical that they knew in advance what was going to happen, one sympathised with Rob and wanted to tell the magpie to "shut up". We felt that life on a struggling station was well represented. We were all interested in the portrayal of the influence of social media, and disagreed with each other over whether the magpie was exploited since Tama was free to fly away. Overall an excellent book for a discussion group, and we couldn't agree on the rating!

Most enjoyed the book - particularly those from rural backgrounds who could relate to the character types. Well-written with lots of layers. Tama provided light relief to what otherwise could have been a rather depressing story.

We all enjoyed this book. Having the magpie speak was a unique way of storytelling. The plot was cleverly thought of and the characters were well defined. An excellent read by a New Zealand writer.

We all enjoyed this book. It was easy and enjoyable to read, yet it wove so many relevant issues into the story in a thought-provoking way, without the reader feeling they were being 'preached' to. We all especially enjoyed the humour in Tama's voice - especially directed at Rob!

Everyone in our group loved this book - although not everyone loves magpies. It was a great story and we all loved the ending. I personally have wanted to read this for so long and it did not disappoint. We would like to read more of her books. Loved the NZ aspect and we could all relate to magpies as most of us have grown up with them around. Decided we would never look at them the same again. Great story - completely different to anything we have read before but it was brilliant.

Great discussion points in this book. Enjoyed by most.

Mixed reactions to this book from the group. Several loved it and thought it deserved 5 stars because it was beautifully written, well researched, an interesting premise, and an exciting plot, others had trouble believing the magpie as a narrator, some felt the writer built up a lot of tension and expectation only for the ending to be anti-climactic, some thought there were too many plot lines that went nowhere and could have been dropped. This wide range of views made it a good discussion book.

All but one of us really enjoyed the book. She couldn't get into it, but we said if she'd persevered she may have. It was remarked on that it was most unusual to have a magpie as the narrator - but good too!! Some good laughs, some awful violence, but a well-written book overall.

All bar two loved this book, a couple even purchasing their own copy!! A very N.Z. book, with that dark undertone.

We all found it compelling, easy to read, a great treatment of serious themes - we were very invested in the characters especially Tama.

Most readers thoroughly enjoyed the book and were very taken with the way the author was able to make Tama such a convincing character. It was a compulsive read. One member did not enjoy as she has an aversion to birds, however she seemed to make an animated contribution to the discussion!

Most members thought this an excellent book. They spoke of the quality and cadence of the language and the interest generated by having the story told from a non-human viewpoint. The magpie narrator spans two worlds and thus provides a revealing perspective on each. All agreed that the author's research was comprehensive and gave immediacy, reality and groundedness to her exploration of the book's themes - including domestic violence, male obsession ( with chopping in this case) as an evasion of unpleasant realities and the impact of the superficially connected world of the internet...

We all found it compelling, easy to read, a great treatment of serious themes - we were very invested in the characters especially Tama.