Map That Changed the World, The
Winchester, Simon
11 Reviews
The fascinating story of an Oxfordshire blacksmith's orphaned son who discovered an unmistakable pattern in the rocks. From this, William "Strata" Smith developed the first true geological map following fossils and rock patterns, earning him a place in history as the father of modern geology. An account of a man who crossed boundaries of class and science.
Comments from Groups
Most readers thought the book fascinating on many levels - time, culture, theology, class etc. We thought the amount of research, time and effort put in by the author was incredible. A bit wordy in places. Palmerston North 002
Most of us had read this book before, or others of Simon Wincester's. We thought that this one stayed more on the subject than some of his others, and was the better for that. We made several criticisms of the book, but small ones, and only because we were trying hard to find something to criticise. An excellent book. Wanganui 011
A variety of opinions - some really enjoyed this and others were bored! But all agreed they had learned a lot. Greytown 001
Most members struggled with the detail of the book, but everyone read it through. It generated a very lively discussion mostly centred on the social systems of that era, with comparisons to modern times, and especially religious thinking. Ohope 001
The subject matter was absorbing, fascinating and educational. The author's style was difficult to read, and not everyone coped with that. For those who persevered, it was well worth it. Nelson 003
Although this book was considered very detailed and repetitive in parts, the group found the history fascinating, and the character of William Smith admirable.... Christchurch 058
Reviews
LOWER 002
10-07-2023
All found this book informative - though one or two felt it was repetitive, with enough technical terms to blunt the interest at times. One person said "It would have been better as an essay".
WESTP 001
10-07-2023
One member brought a geological map of our area to the meeting. This gave us some understanding of the land around us and of the work William Smith did that is so useful today. The book was "wordy" but most members found it an interesting historical story.
PALMN 016
10-07-2023
Our group thoroughly enjoyed this book and found it provided many insights into the social history of the times in which William Smith lived and worked. Recommended.
WHANG 001
10-07-2023
Two of our group thoroughly enjoyed the book. However, the remainder found it a bit too long-winded in the description of geology. All found it a very interesting social commentary on the times portrayed. Not sure we enjoyed Simon Winchester's style of writing - didn't feel we got a clear idea of who William Smith really was.
MARTIN 001
10-07-2023
Most enjoyed the idea of the book but thought it too long and repetitive.
QUEEN 003
10-07-2023
Some of our group found there was just too much information to absorb. The print is very small and close together. We all enjoyed the historical features especially of the Industrial Revolution. Simon Winchester had done a tremendous amount of research, for which he acknowledged his helpers. More personal details about William Smith's nephew would have been good - perhaps there is another book there.
CHCH 277
10-07-2023
A fascinating book which was enjoyed by all. The author's enthusiasm for his subject was particularly appreciated.
DUNED 044
10-07-2023
A very hard read.
AUCK 443
10-07-2023
We felt the book is an engaging account of an extraordinary man, enticingly written of his multiple talents, triumphs and ruin. Somewhat repetitive and for some readers, rather too much diversion, although an interesting and informative background. We are enthused to seek out the author's other works.
CHCH 294
10-07-2023
Only three of the group finished reading it. Topic excellent but the writing was tedious and boring.
AUCK 100
11-05-2022
Those in the group who read the book particularly enjoyed the biography and history. At times the book was very scientific, but this was relieved by the wonderful language and humour the author used.